Showing posts with label Medieval catholicism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medieval catholicism. Show all posts

Thursday, December 14, 2023

A short review of Gentile Tales: The Narrative Assault on Late Medieval Jews by Miri Rubin

 Rubin, Miri. Gentile Tales: The Narrative Assault on Late Medieval Jews. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999.

Anti-Jewish tales of conspiracy and evil deeds echoed throughout the Medieval period, leading to a constant air of suspicion toward Jews in Europe. The assumption that Jews were not to be trusted and required a constant watch of their activities led to serious consequences between the Christian majority and the Jewish minority. Perhaps the allegation carrying the greatest weight in the eyes of many Christians was the frequent tale accusing Jews of the desecration of the Eucharistic host. Miri Rubin in her book, Gentile Tales: The Narrative Assault on Late Medieval Jews examines both the story of Jewish host desecration and the history and consequences as the tales of host desecration spread.

Host desecration.In Wikipedia. 

Rubin begins her study with an inquiry into the narrative mode. The narrative serves a purpose as a cultural container and a vehicle for action. “Whole cultural systems are carried in myths, and myth is carried in rituals and through narratives. People act through narratives, and they remember through narrative.” (2-3) The author’s goal is to place the anti-Jewish tales of host desecration within the “contexts of its production and telling.” (4) Within the Introductory chapter, the claims of host desecration contained “both history and story and thus encompassed authority and universality while allowing space for individual participation and the working of fantasy.” (2) According to Rubin, both narrative and textuality are needed instruments to understanding the tales within their historical setting. While the tales are impacted by the setting and circumstances of their telling they offer a snapshot into the attitudes and prejudices of many medieval Christians at that time. Rubin aims to present the development of the “dangerous representations” that empower those who spread the tales and use the tales of host desecration to justify their actions. (5)

16th-century painting showing the alleged desecration of hosts by Jews in Passau in 1477 from Wikipedia

Rubin focuses on the large number of stories and myths regarding host desecration by Jews and the violent aftermath of the tales. The narrative presented by Rubin begins at the end of the thirteenth century and continues during the following two centuries. The stories follow a pattern with a Jew determined to secure the consecrated host often with the aid of a female fooled or bribed. Once procured the host undergoes attacks and experiments from the Jewish thief resulting in miraculous demonstrations of flesh or blood. Once the deception and desecration are exposed, the Jewish thief faces severe punishment and the miracle of the host appears vindicated often with Jewish conversions. Above all, Gentile Tales reveals the power of narratives to compel action and violence, as seen in the violence perpetrated against Jewish communities.

Medieval Anti-Semitism from the Wiener Holocaust Library

Rubin begins her book with an introduction followed by chapter one exploring the earliest medieval narratives. The earliest narratives often stressed Jewish conversions after confrontation with the power of the host. Central to her exploration of the early tales is the Jewish boy tale. A Jewish boy faces punishment from his father after receiving communion. The father throws his son into the oven, but the boy receives protection from Mary, who protects him with her cloak. The miracle results in the conversion of the boy and his mother, while the father receives a just punishment when he faces death within the oven. Rubin then proceeds to detail the development of the tale as it spread from its Greek origins to different regions of Christian Europe. The development of the tales led to a growing stress on the evil motives and the punishment of Jews after the appearance of eucharistic miracles. The movement toward Jewish perfidy increased in the view of the tales offering “no place for forgiveness, ending in revenge and destruction.” (39) The Jew became a figure of suspicion, an enemy worthy only of banishment or death.

Chapter 3 titled “Patterns of Accusation” begins with the 1290 case in Paris and explores how the Jews faced accusations of host desecration. The Paris accusation was the first complete tale of host desecration but saw parallel development of the narrative in different European regions. The Holy Week became a popular setting for many tales as the suspicion of Jewish treachery increased during periods considered holy and special.

Chapter 4 titled “Persons and Places” presents the cast of characters and locations typical in many of the eucharistic desecrations. In most of the tales, the primary villain is a circumcised male Jew. Often a single Jew might prompt a group of Jews into action, but in most cases, the primary instigator is a single male Talmud-Jew. This devious Jewish man often finds assistance from a gullible Christian female who is easily bribed or tricked into obtaining the host. Initially, the Jewish man appears normal but underneath “lurked the unusual, the dangerous, the menacing.” (70) Within Chapter 5, Rubin examines the contexts and the background of a number of the accusation cases. Here she examines the aspects that made the tales work and motivate the hearers. In chapter 6, the author looks at the “commemorative tokens” of the violence following the host desecration tales. The stories reinforced Christian identity while at the same time emphasizing the disparity with Jews. (132) Memorials to the tales found in art or text remain difficult to discern as “every act of memory is also an act of forgetting.” (133) In her conclusion, Rubin traces the decline of the accusations that led to violence against Jews and eventually lost much of its “potency” as sacramental language changed near the end of the fifteenth century.

Rubin presents a rather dense but challenging book. The sources shared make for difficult reading but offer a challenge to the damage caused by demagoguery and stereotypes. Her interjection of “What do Jews Think of the Eucharist?” discusses the limited evidence of Jewish thought but also provides a voice for the Jewish victims and reveal the diversity within Europe. But Rubin effectively reveals the power of stories to move people to action and often to acts of violence and oppression.


Medieval people became willing executioners on occasions not because this came naturally to them, but when and only when the act of violence became the most compelling way of making sense of the world and asserting identity and interest. (193)

Gentile Tales is a valuable addition to Jewish and medieval history. The addition of a basic bibliography and introduction providing past research and historiography of her work would greatly improve the usefulness of the book.

 

 

 

 

Clare of Assisi and the Thirteenth-Century Church: Religious Women, Rules, and Resistance by Catherine Mooney a Short Review

 Mooney, Catherine M. Clare of Assisi and the Thirteenth-Century Church: Religious Women, Rules, and Resistance. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016.

The task of separating true history from legend is a daunting task when researching medieval religious figures. Folklore is easily mixed with historical facts as the life of a devout saint grows in importance to a spiritual community. The life of Clare of Assisi is an excellent example of a medieval saint with a biography supported by sources containing religious accounts that make historical investigation difficult. Catherine Mooney takes up the challenge in her work, Clare of Assisi and the Thirteenth-Century Church: Religious Women, Rules, and Resistance. From the beginning, Mooney acknowledges the difficulty in fully understanding the historical details of Clare’s life since much of her life remains frozen through the lenses of faith.

For Mooney the challenge is to locate the authentic Clare between “history” and “hagiography.” (5) Eyewitness testimonies remain a challenge for the author as these hagiographic accounts were prepared for the process of Clare’s canonization. Yet, these accounts remain meaningful because these voices recorded soon after the death of Clare reflect important thoughts about the period and the subject. Mooney takes the hagiographic stories recorded close to Clare’s into account and compares them with surviving documents. The author uses sources such as letters, religious rules, papal documents, biographies, and hagiographic accounts to construct a bare-bones or minimalist account of Clare of Assisi to avoid telling a life based on assumptions and “unconscious circular reasoning.” (9) Mooney’s work is not a traditional biography but she provides an exceptional example of the balance between a historian using both traditional primary sources and hagiography while providing contextualization and understanding of her subject and setting. While providing a minimalist account of Clare, Mooney provides a picture of a woman committed to her faith and vision. Clare remained a woman willing to stand before papal pressure in her quest to fulfill her vow of poverty within her community.

From Secular Franciscans 

Mooney divides her book into an introduction discussing her sources and methodology along with nine chapters. The first chapter offers evidence of Clare’s childhood and early life. Much of the basis for this chapter derives from three hagiographic texts which offer a sharp contrast to her later adult life. Especially important is the contact with Francis of Assisi, whose example and guidance set the pattern for Clare’s life. Chapter 2 deals with her first years in the community of San Damiano as both Clare and her sisters found a home and a “form of life” (forma vitae) under the inspiration of Francis. The third and fourth chapters center on recent scholarship that presents a clearer picture of Clare and the penitent women within the Order of San Damiano and the leading role of Cardinal Hugo (later Pope Gregory IX) in forming the order and his often difficult relationship with Clare. The death of Francis of Assisi leaves Clare and the sisters without a protector with Gregory IX working at rebranding San Damiano into a leading house of a new order. Throughout this process, Clare remains intent on preserving the original mission of her community.

Agnes of Prague from Wikipedia

Chapter 5 focuses on the spiritual guidance Clare gives to Agnes of Prague using surviving letters that preserve Clare’s voice and reveal the difficulties existing between Clare and the papacy. Chapter 6 continues an examination of the relationship between Pope Gregory and the community at San Damiano as they chose to follow the forma vitae laid down by Francis ignoring the instructions of the papacy. The struggle continues in chapter 7 as Pope Innocent IV issues a new forma vitae that tied juridically the Order of San Damiano to the Lesser Brothers. Innocent’s rules were not sincerely received and his forma vitae failed to take hold. The eighth chapter examines the 1253 Forma Vitae that attempted to include the desires of San Damiano with those of the papacy. Numerous scholars believed that the 1253 document originated from the hand of Clare but Mooney offers evidence that it was the composition of Rainaldo of Jenne as the principal author. While Clare was not the primary redactor of the 1253 rules, the Forma Vitae reflects her desire to preserve the community and the contributions of all the sisters. The attribution of the 1253 document to Clare alone derived from “faulty manuscript analysis and weak scholarly conjecture.” (219) The final chapter looks at Clare’s final years through her later letters to Agnes of Prague. The letters reflect the intense intimacy between Clare and Agnes and Clare’s strong desire to maintain a community that lived poorly and humbly. To the very end of Clare’s life, it was evident that she desired to secure the independence of her community within the ideal of poverty set forth by Francis of Assisi.

A Portrait of Saint Francis by Philip Fruytiers

                                                          from Wikipedia

Mooney rejects the idea of Clare as a “great woman” of history as she claims it distorts the image of Clare and reduces the role of the community of women. In many ways, Mooney reduces the role of Clare as the sole founder of a religious community, yet still recognizes the role of Clare in her struggles with papal authority as a woman of strength and perseverance. Clare was a “charismatic and determined leader,” but she belonged to a strong network of women determined to set their own path. (215) While Mooney’s work presents a challenge for the causal reader of medieval religious history, her ingenious use of her sources presents a fine illustration for historians who face similar obstacles when facing sources derived from hagiographic accounts. The challenge of dealing authentically with the issue of history and hagiography remains a task for all historians.